"Poggio Nardone's 2017 Rosso di Montalcino (with 35,000 bottles produced) is a wine of extreme equilibrium and balance. Given the scorching heat and dryness of the vintage, this wine is remarkable. I highly recommend this easygoing Rosso for informal pasta or pizza dinners at home. The wine is soft and round; however, it still maintains that characteristic Sangiovese freshness and perkiness. It opens to a deeply saturated color and a lean mouthfeel with aromas of black fruit and plum. You taste that Rosso simplicity in the mouth. Some 35,000 bottles were made. - Monica Larner"

- Robert Parker's Wine Advocate (Issue #241, February 2019), 90+ points

"A red with attractive fruit and walnut undertones, delivering plenty of character and enjoyment as a simple rosso. It’s medium-bodied with firm yet creamy-textured tannins and a delicious finish. Drink now."

- James Suckling (August 2020), 91 points

"Aromas of red fruit, rosemary and white smoke. Medium-bodied with bright acidity. Pleasant, savory herbs on the palate. Wet-stone finish. Drink now."

- James Suckling (September 2021), 90 points